Published by Oravbiere Osayomore Promise.
Former Manchester United defender Patrice Evra has launched an extraordinary verbal assault on ex-Arsenal winger Theo Walcott, branding him a “menace to society” and insisting he should never work on television again for daring to compare the current Arsenal squad to Manchester United’s iconic 2008 team. The controversy began in January during a live broadcast on Amazon Prime, where Walcott, working as a pundit alongside Wayne Rooney, asked his former England teammate how Mikel Arteta’s side would fare against the legendary United team that won the Premier League and Champions League double in 2008. Rooney’s immediate response was blunt: “We’d batter them.” Nearly three months later, Evra has resurrected the debate with a series of incendiary comments that have reignited the fierce rivalry between the two clubs and drawn sharp criticism from Arsenal supporters.
Evra, a key member of that 2008 United squad alongside Rio Ferdinand, Wayne Rooney, and Cristiano Ronaldo, did not hold back when asked about Walcott’s question during an episode of the Rio Ferdinand Presents podcast. The Frenchman, who won five Premier League titles and the Champions League during his time at Old Trafford, appeared genuinely incensed that anyone would compare Arteta’s current project to the team that Sir Alex Ferguson assembled nearly two decades ago. “That’s the problem with Arsenal. Now he’s comparing this team with our 2008 team,” Evra said, according to multiple reports. He then escalated his criticism to an extraordinary level, stating: “I think he’s a menace for society. He should not be on TV. He’s dangerous for the kids. That’s why I keep saying they are delusional.” The former left-back, known for his passionate and often unfiltered opinions, doubled down by declaring that Walcott’s line of questioning was fundamentally disrespectful to the legacy of United’s 2008 squad. “This is disrespect. He should never be on TV again when he starts asking questions like that,” Evra added.
The 2008 Manchester United team is widely regarded as one of the greatest sides in Premier League history. Under the legendary management of Sir Alex Ferguson, the squad featuring Cristiano Ronaldo, Wayne Rooney, Carlos Tevez, Rio Ferdinand, and Edwin van der Sar secured the Premier League title and famously defeated Chelsea on penalties in the Champions League final in Moscow. That season, United played an exhilarating brand of attacking football, with Ronaldo scoring 42 goals across all competitions and winning his first Ballon d’Or. The team’s achievements place it in the pantheon of English football’s greatest sides, alongside Arsenal’s “Invincibles” of 2003-04 and Manchester City’s treble winners of 2022-23. In contrast, while Arteta’s Arsenal has shown significant progress in the 2025-26 season, the club has not won a Premier League title since 2004 and has not lifted the Champions League in its history. The Gunners have pushed Manchester City to the wire in the title race on multiple occasions in recent years, but have consistently fallen short at the final hurdle.
Walcott’s original question, posed in January during Arsenal’s Champions League victory over Inter Milan, was more nuanced than Evra’s reaction suggests. The former Arsenal winger, who spent 12 years at the Emirates Stadium, acknowledged United’s superiority by calling the 2008 side “probably the best team that I’ve ever played against.” He then asked Rooney for his assessment of how Arteta’s current squad would compare. Rooney’s response was characteristically direct, but he did so with a smile, and Walcott himself appeared to take the answer in good humor. However, the passage of time has not cooled tempers. Evra’s comments, made in late April, come at a particularly sensitive moment for Arsenal.
The Gunners have seen their once commanding lead at the top of the Premier League evaporate in recent weeks. A 2-1 defeat to Manchester City on April 20 cut Arsenal’s advantage to just three points, with all the momentum now seemingly with Pep Guardiola’s defending champions. Additionally, Arsenal’s EFL Cup final defeat to City has raised the specter of another trophyless season, lending an unfortunate timing to Walcott’s earlier optimism.
Reaction to Evra’s outburst has been swift and divided. Many Manchester United supporters have rallied behind their former captain, agreeing that comparisons between the current Arsenal side and the 2008 treble-winners are premature at best and laughable at worst. “Evra is speaking the truth.
Arsenal haven’t earned the right to be mentioned in the same breath as that United team,” one fan posted on social media. Conversely, Arsenal fans have accused Evra of arrogance and of deliberately stirring controversy for attention. “It’s just a pundit asking a question. Walcott even said United were better. Evra is overreacting and it’s embarrassing,” another user countered. The debate has also drawn in other football figures, with some neutral observers noting that while the 2008 United team was undoubtedly superior, Evra’s language was unnecessarily harsh and personal toward Walcott.
As the Premier League season enters its final weeks, the focus will return to the pitch, where Arsenal face a desperate battle to hold off Manchester City and secure their first league title in over two decades. For Walcott, the controversy is an unwanted distraction from his burgeoning media career.
For Evra, it is another opportunity to defend the legacy of the team he holds so dear. Whether the Frenchman’s comments will have any lasting impact remains to be seen, but they have certainly added fuel to the fire of English football’s most enduring rivalries. One thing is certain: the debate over which era produced the best team will continue to rage among fans and pundits alike for years to come.
📩 Stone Reporters News | 🌍 stonereportersnews.com
✉️ info@stonereportersnews.com | 📘 Facebook: Stone Reporters News | 🐦 X (Twitter): @StoneReportNew | 📸 Instagram: @stonereportersnews
Add comment
Comments