Reported by: Oahimire Omone Precious | Edited by: Oravbiere Osayomore Promise.
In a significant development from Damaturu, the capital of Yobe State, Nigeria, a Chief Magistrate’s Court has discharged and acquitted a man who had been on trial for more than three years over allegations of assault against a minor. The ruling marks the culmination of a legal process that began in 2021, ending in the court’s finding that the prosecution failed to establish a credible case against the accused.
The defendant, Uche Friday Uche, faced a charge that accused him of using criminal force with intent to outrage the modesty of a girl, an offence under Section 268 of the Penal Code which governs offences against the person and public morality in northern states that retain aspects of the code. The prosecution, instituted by the Commissioner of Police, brought the suit to the Chief Magistrate’s Court under case number YBS/DT/CMC‑I/19/2021 in 2021, alleging that Uche unlawfully assaulted a minor — a serious allegation that carried significant legal and social consequences.
Throughout the trial, the prosecution, led by M. H. Muhammad, called witnesses and presented evidence intended to prove that Uche had committed the offence. The specifics of the testimony and exhibits were not publicly detailed in court reports, but the government’s case was framed within the gravity of protecting children and upholding the dignity and safety of minors — a central focus of Nigerian criminal law.
On the other side, Uche’s legal representative, defence counsel S. S. Karasuwa, argued forcefully that the available evidence did not meet the minimum legal standard required to sustain a prima facie case — the preliminary showing that would justify continuing the trial. The defence maintained that without clear, credible evidence linking Uche to the alleged offence, the matter should not proceed to a full determination.
After reviewing the submissions from both sides, the presiding magistrate, Mohammed Bilyaminu, ruled in favour of the defence, holding that the prosecution had failed to establish a prima facie case. In his ruling, the magistrate said that the evidence presented by the state did not reach the threshold necessary to warrant further legal proceedings or a conviction. As a result, he struck out the charge and formally discharged and acquitted Uche, effectively clearing him of all allegations related to the complaint.
“The prosecution has not established a prima facie case to justify further proceedings,” the magistrate stated, reflecting the long‑standing legal principle that the burden of proof in criminal cases lies with the state and must be satisfied before a person can be lawfully convicted.
Uche’s arrest in 2021 followed a complaint that he had used criminal force with intent to outrage a girl’s modesty, an allegation that carries heavy social stigma as well as serious criminal implications. The fact that the case dragged on for over three years highlights broader challenges in Nigeria’s justice system, particularly in cases involving alleged offences against children where evidence, witness testimony, and procedural demands are often complex.
The court’s decision underscores the principle of presumption of innocence — that every suspect is considered innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt. Nigerian criminal jurisprudence places this burden squarely on the prosecution, especially in matters involving allegations of harm to minors where evidentiary standards are necessarily high to protect both the rights of the accused and the dignity of alleged victims.
Legal observers say the ruling may also reflect wider systemic issues within law enforcement and prosecution teams, particularly around the quality of investigations in sensitive cases. In recent years, security agencies in Yobe State have reported multiple arrests in cases involving sexual assault and gender-based violence, including actions against suspects accused of assaulting young girls. These arrests, which often result in prosecution, point to ongoing efforts by authorities to address such crimes while also highlighting challenges in securing convictions where evidence must withstand judicial scrutiny.
The acquittal of Uche also arrives amid a backdrop of public conversations about child protection and justice. Advocacy groups around Nigeria have voiced concerns about how cases involving alleged offences against minors are handled, pushing for stronger investigative processes, forensic support, and rights-based approaches that balance victim protection with fair trial guarantees for suspects. These debates often gain traction in communities where delays or dismissals in court can fuel public frustration and calls for reform.
While some may view the court’s ruling as a vindication of legal principles, others have expressed unease about how allegations involving children are addressed by law enforcement and the judiciary. Critics often urge more rigorous investigative procedures and timely prosecutions to ensure that legitimate complaints are backed by solid evidence before reaching the courtroom, while also safeguarding defendants from wrongful accusations.
For Uche and his family, the court’s decision brings an end to a prolonged period of legal uncertainty and social strain. His acquittal restores his legal standing and absolves him of the charges that had hung over him for more than three years. The outcome also reinforces the judiciary’s role in upholding constitutional protections and evidentiary standards, reminding both prosecutors and the public that allegations must be substantiated with credible proof before the law can rightfully convict.
As Nigeria continues to grapple with protecting vulnerable populations and ensuring justice, cases like this one spotlight the delicate balance between pursuing accountability and maintaining the fundamental rights of individuals within the legal system.
📩 Stone Reporters News | 🌍 stonereportersnews.com
✉️ info@stonereportersnews.com | 📘 Facebook: Stone Reporters | 🐦 X (Twitter): @StoneReportNew | 📸 Instagram: @stonereportersnews
Add comment
Comments