Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes has questioned manager Michael Carrick's tactical approach following the club's humiliating 4–1 defeat to Italian side Como in the UEFA Champions League, arguing that the team's failure to press aggressively allowed their opponents to dominate possession and dictate the game.
The defeat occurred on Wednesday, October 21, 2026, at the Stadio Giuseppe Sinigaglia in Como, where Manchester United conceded after just two minutes and struggled to recover, extending their winless run across all competitions to seven matches.
Speaking to TNT Sports after the game, Fernandes criticised United's approach without directly accusing Carrick of being solely responsible for the result.
The Portuguese midfielder explained that the coaching staff had instructed players not to press their opponents individually, instead allowing Como more possession while attempting to regain the ball in selected areas.
According to Fernandes, the approach gave the Italian side too much freedom to build attacks and establish control of the match.
He argued that allowing technically capable opponents extended periods on the ball could make defending increasingly difficult, leaving players physically and mentally exhausted when possession was eventually recovered.
The United captain suggested that his team needed to demonstrate greater courage when confronting opponents capable of controlling possession.
“Sometimes you have to be more brave under pressure,” Fernandes said, advocating a more aggressive pressing approach to disrupt the opposition.
However, when asked whether his remarks amounted to criticism of Carrick's tactical decisions, Fernandes maintained that assessing those choices was the responsibility of the manager and coaching staff.
His comments nevertheless exposed a disagreement over United's defensive approach following another disappointing European performance.
Como made an immediate impact when Nico Paz scored in the second minute, putting the home side ahead before United had settled into the contest.
The Italian club continued to exploit United's defensive weaknesses, with Tasos Douvikas extending their advantage shortly after half-time.
Paz added his second goal in the 57th minute before Jacobo Ramón made it 4–0 in the closing stages.
Joshua Zirkzee eventually scored a consolation goal for Manchester United in stoppage time, but the late effort did little to change the outcome.
The defeat left United with three points from their opening three Champions League matches and intensified scrutiny of Carrick's management.
Fernandes expressed particular concern about the team's reaction to conceding early.
He suggested that the players appeared to lose confidence after falling behind, making it increasingly difficult to recover their organisation and attacking momentum.
The midfielder acknowledged that the team had struggled with similar situations previously and called for greater resilience when matches began badly.
Carrick, meanwhile, accepted overall responsibility for the defeat but also questioned the intensity and commitment shown by his players.
The United manager described the performance as unacceptable and apologised to the club's supporters.
Responding to Fernandes's comments about pressing, Carrick argued that changing the defensive system would not solve the team's problems unless players consistently fulfilled their responsibilities.
He pointed out that United had attempted a more aggressive pressing approach during the second half but still conceded.
The manager maintained that players needed to work harder when recovering their defensive positions, regardless of the tactical instructions.
His response suggested that he regarded the team's difficulties as involving both tactical execution and individual effort.
Carrick also expressed frustration at the manner of the defeat, stressing that Manchester United could not afford performances lacking the required determination and intensity.
The result represents another setback in a difficult start to the season for the English club.
United have struggled to establish consistency domestically and in Europe, with their performances increasingly attracting criticism from supporters and football analysts.
The defeat to Como also highlighted concerns about the team's ability to cope with opponents who retain possession and move the ball effectively through midfield.
According to Sky Sports, Como completed 594 passes during the encounter, the highest total recorded by an opponent against Manchester United in the Champions League since Barcelona completed 725 in April 2019.
The statistic illustrates the extent to which the Italian side controlled possession during significant periods of the match.
However, possession figures alone do not establish whether the tactical approach or the players' execution was primarily responsible for the result.
Fernandes's comments reflected his belief that United should have applied greater pressure, while Carrick emphasised the need for consistent effort regardless of the system.
The differing assessments have added to questions surrounding the relationship between the manager's tactical instructions and the team's performances.
United's immediate challenge will be to respond positively when they return to Premier League action against Bournemouth on Sunday.
The club is also scheduled to face Roma in its next Champions League fixture, providing another opportunity to improve its position in the competition.
For Carrick, the coming matches will bring further scrutiny of his tactical decisions and ability to restore consistency.
For Fernandes and his teammates, the challenge will be to translate their post-match concerns into improved performances.
Although the captain questioned the tactical approach, he did not claim that the manager alone caused the defeat.
Instead, his remarks highlighted the need for greater aggression, confidence and coordination as Manchester United attempt to recover from another damaging result.
📩 Stone Reporters News | 🌍 stonereportersnews.com
✉️ info@stonereportersnews.com | 📘 Facebook: Stone Reporters News | 🐦 X (Twitter): @StoneReportNew | 📸 Instagram: @stonereportersnews
Add comment
Comments